WaterRowing Machine Walnut Rowing Machine S4 or WaterRowing Machine Club Rowing Machine S4? Which WaterRowing Machine Model to Buy
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Links on this page are affiliate links.
Choosing between the waterrower walnut rowing machine s4 vs club rowing machine s4 depends on your space and aesthetic preferences. Both are handcrafted in the USA and use the same S4 BLE monitor and water resistance. The main difference lies in the wood and dimensions. The Walnut model features a rich, varied grain, while the Club uses solid Ash. You also need to check the footprint carefully, as the Club is slightly wider and heavier. This guide breaks down the specs to help you decide.
Key differences
| Aspect | WaterRower Walnut S4 Handcrafted Rower | WaterRower Club S4 Water Rower |
|---|---|---|
| Wood Type | Walnut | Solid Ash |
| Weight | 61.7 lbs | 117 lbs |
| Width | 84 inches | 24 inches |
| Height | 22 inches | 21 inches |
| Length | 21 inches | 83 inches |
Which one should you choose?
Choose WaterRower Walnut S4 Handcrafted Rower if
- You prefer a machine with a distinctive, high-end walnut grain finish.
- You want a lighter unit that is easier to move around your home.
- You value a wider footprint for added stability during intense rows.
Choose WaterRower Club S4 Water Rower if
- You want a classic, uniform Ash wood stain that fits traditional decor.
- You need a slightly more compact height for lower ceilings.
- You prefer a heavier, more stable base for a solid feel.
Verdict: The Walnut model suits you if you prioritize visual uniqueness and a lighter frame. The Club model is better if you prefer a standard Ash finish and a slightly lower profile. Both offer the same rowing experience and S4 monitor functionality.
Walnut S4 vs Club S4 Comparison
build material
The WaterRower Walnut S4 Handcrafted Rower features a signature chocolate-brown walnut finish, with each piece showing unique grain patterns and tones. This model emphasizes aesthetic complexity. In contrast, the WaterRower Club S4 Water Rower is handcrafted in solid Ash and stained for color. While both machines share the same handcrafted heritage and ethically sourced timber from Appalachian hardwood forests, the Walnut model offers a distinct, premium wood appearance. The Club model provides a more uniform, stained look. Your choice here depends on whether you prefer the natural variation of walnut or the consistent finish of stained ash.
dimensions
You will notice significant differences in the footprint and height of these rowers. The WaterRower Club S4 Water Rower measures 83 inches in length, 24 inches in width, and 21 inches in height. It is classified as a Lo-Rise model. The WaterRower Walnut S4 Handcrafted Rower is listed with a width of 84 inches, a height of 22 inches, and a length of 21 inches in its specific specs section, though the general description cites 82 inches in length and 22 inches in height. These variations suggest the Club model may have a wider stance or different rail configuration. You should verify the exact footprint against your available space before deciding.
weight
Weight capacity and machine mass differ between the two models. The WaterRower Club S4 Water Rower has a stated weight of 117 pounds. This heavier build may contribute to a more stable rowing experience during intense sessions. The WaterRower Walnut S4 Handcrafted Rower is listed with a weight of 61.7 pounds in its specific specs, though the feature description mentions a weight of 103.5 pounds with water. The discrepancy likely arises from whether the water is included. Generally, the Club model appears to have a higher static weight, which can be an advantage for stability. You should consider how much floor space and structural support you have for a heavier unit.
display type
Both rowing machines come equipped with the S4 BLE Monitor. This display provides Bluetooth Low Energy connectivity, allowing you to sync your workout data with compatible fitness apps and devices. The connectivity and display technology are identical across both the WaterRower Walnut S4 Handcrafted Rower and the WaterRower Club S4 Water Rower. This means you will have the same tracking capabilities, performance metrics, and digital integration regardless of which wood type you choose. The monitor is a standard feature on both models, ensuring you get the same digital experience.
resistance type
The resistance mechanism is the same for both units. Both the WaterRower Walnut S4 Handcrafted Rower and the WaterRower Club S4 Water Rower use a water-filled flywheel to create resistance. As you row, the paddle-like blades move through the water, providing a smooth, natural feel that mimics actual rowing on water. The harder you pull, the more resistance you encounter. This system is low impact and targets 84 percent of total muscle mass, including legs, core, back, and arms. Since the resistance type is identical, your workout feel will be consistent between the two models.
Which WaterRower S4 Fits Your Space
Users with limited floor space
The WaterRower Walnut S4 measures 84 inches wide and 21 inches high. Its narrower footprint allows for easier placement in tighter areas. The lower height profile may suit shorter users better. You get the same water resistance and S4 BLE monitor connectivity, but the compact dimensions make it the practical choice for smaller rooms.
Buyers wanting solid Ash construction
The WaterRower Club S4 is handcrafted in solid Ash. This wood type offers a different aesthetic and structural feel compared to Walnut. It weighs 117 pounds, providing a stable base during intense rowing sessions. The Lo-Rise design suits taller users. You receive the same USA-made quality and water flywheel resistance as the Walnut model.
Those prioritizing unique wood grain
Each Walnut S4 unit displays unique grain patterns with tones of gray, red, and purple. This model emphasizes aesthetic complexity through its natural Walnut finish. If you value distinct visual character in home gym equipment, this handcrafted piece stands out. You still get the full-body workout benefits and the integrated S4 BLE monitor for tracking your performance.
The products compared
WaterRower Walnut S4 Handcrafted Rower
Best for: Users seeking handcrafted durability and natural water resistance
- Resistance Type
- water
- Intended Use
- Home Use
- Dimensions
- 21 × 84 × 22 inches
- Weight
- 61.7 pounds
View on Amazon: WaterRower Walnut S4 Handcrafted Rower Affiliate link
The WaterRower Walnut S4 is a handcrafted rowing machine built in the USA. It uses water resistance for a smooth, natural feel that scales with your effort. The S4 BLE Monitor tracks your workout data. It measures 84 inches long and weighs 61.7 pounds without water. This model suits those who want a durable, aesthetically pleasing home gym tool that targets 84 percent of muscle mass.
Pros
- Handcrafted walnut wood construction
- Water flywheel resistance
- S4 BLE Monitor connectivity
- USA made
Cons
- Large footprint at 84 inches long
- Heavier build requires sturdy flooring
- No heart rate sensors included
Good fit if
- You want a durable, handcrafted rower
- You prefer natural water resistance
- You have space for a long machine
Skip if
- You need a compact storage solution
- You want digital app integration
- You prefer electronic resistance levels
Verdict: WaterRower Walnut S4 Rowing Machine is ideal for users who value craftsmanship and natural resistance over digital features. It fits homes with ample floor space and a desire for a long-lasting, USA-made fitness tool.
WaterRower Club S4 Water Rower
Best for: natural water resistance and wood build
- Resistance Type
- water
- Weight Capacity
- 103.5 lbs (with water)
- Display Type
- S4 BLE Monitor
- Connectivity
- BLE
- Intended Use
- Home Use
- Dimensions
- 83 × 24 × 21 inches
View on Amazon: WaterRower Club S4 Water Rower Affiliate link
This WaterRower Club model uses a water-filled flywheel for smooth, natural resistance. It features an S4 BLE Monitor to track your workout data. The frame is handcrafted from solid ash wood. It measures 83 inches long and weighs 117 pounds. This unit is designed for home use and targets major muscle groups with a low-impact full-body workout.
Pros
- Water-filled flywheel provides smooth, natural resistance
- S4 BLE Monitor for workout tracking
- Handcrafted solid ash wood construction
- Low-impact full-body exercise
Cons
- Large footprint at 83 inches long
- Heavy weight of 117 pounds
- No remote control included
Good fit if
- You want a low-impact full-body workout
- You prefer natural water resistance
- You value handcrafted wooden furniture
Skip if
- You have limited floor space
- You need a lightweight machine
- You require app connectivity
Verdict: WaterRower Club S4 Water Rower is a sturdy, space-intensive option for those who prioritize natural water resistance and wood craftsmanship over compact storage or digital features.
Specifications side by side
| Spec | WaterRower Walnut S4 Handcrafted Rower | WaterRower Club S4 Water Rower |
|---|---|---|
| Resistance Type | water | water |
| Weight Capacity | not stated | 103.5 lbs (with water) |
| Display Type | not stated | S4 BLE Monitor |
| Connectivity | not stated | BLE |
| Intended Use | Home Use | Home Use |
| Dimensions | 21 × 84 × 22 inches | 83 × 24 × 21 inches |
| Weight | 61.7 pounds | 117 pounds |
| Color | Walnut | Lo-Rise |
| Model | Walnut S4 | Club S4 |
| Size | not stated | Lo-Rise |
Frequently asked questions
Is the WaterRower Club S4 heavier than the Walnut model?
Yes, the Club S4 is significantly heavier. It weighs 117 pounds, while the Walnut S4 weighs 61.7 pounds. This extra weight provides greater stability during intense rowing sessions. The added mass helps keep the machine steady on the floor.
Which model has a lower height profile?
Both models share the same height of 21 inches. The Club S4 is listed at 21 inches, and the Walnut S4 is also 21 inches high. You will find no difference in vertical clearance between the two options.
Does the Club S4 take up more floor space?
The footprint dimensions differ slightly. The Club S4 is 24 inches wide, whereas the Walnut S4 is 84 inches wide. However, both share a similar length of approximately 21 to 24 inches depending on orientation. Check your room layout carefully.
What type of wood is used in the Club S4?
The Club S4 is handcrafted in solid Ash. It is stained to achieve its final color. This contrasts with the Walnut S4, which uses natural walnut wood. The Ash construction offers a different aesthetic and grain pattern for your home.
Are both machines suitable for home use?
Yes, both the Walnut S4 and Club S4 are designed for home use. They provide natural water resistance for effective workouts. Their durable construction ensures they can handle regular exercise routines in a residential setting without commercial-grade wear.
Do both models use water resistance?
Both the WaterRower Walnut S4 and Club S4 utilize water resistance. This type of resistance scales with your effort, providing a smooth and natural feel. You will experience consistent performance regardless of which model you choose to purchase.
Is the Walnut S4 lighter for moving?
The Walnut S4 is lighter at 61.7 pounds. The Club S4 weighs 117 pounds. If you need to move the rower frequently, the Walnut model is easier to handle. The lighter weight aids in transportation and repositioning within your home.