3 Best WaterRowing Machine Rowing Machines Under $1500, Compared

Quick picks

The best fit for you

• You want connected training and durable home use WaterRower Vintage Oak S4 BLE It features the S4 monitor for connected training and USA-made construction.
• You seek natural wood aesthetics and water resistance WaterRower Solid Ash Wood Rower It offers a premium, natural ash wood finish with authentic water resistance.
• You value handcrafted durability in a dedicated home gym WaterRower Club S4 Water Rower It is a heavy, 117-pound unit built for handcrafted durability.

Our 3 picks

1 Best overall

WaterRower Vintage Oak S4 BLE

Best for: Connected training and durable home use

Resistance Type

Water

Connectivity

Bluetooth, WaterRower Connect, CITYROW

Dimensions

83 × 21 × 22 inches

Weight

108 pounds

View on Amazon: WaterRower Vintage Oak S4 BLE Affiliate link

This WaterRower uses a water flywheel for resistance that scales with your effort. It features the S4 BLE monitor for tracking performance and connects to digital training ecosystems. The frame is solid oak, measuring 83 by 21 inches. It weighs 108 pounds and stores upright. This model suits those seeking a durable, USA-made rower with connected training options.

Pros

• Water flywheel provides responsive, self-regulating resistance.
• S4 BLE monitor tracks performance and connects to apps.
• Solid oak frame made in the USA.
• Stores upright to save floor space.

Cons

• Large footprint at 83 inches long.
• Heavy at 108 pounds.
• No heart-rate sensors listed in specifications.

Good fit if

• You want a connected training experience via the S4 BLE monitor.
• You prefer the natural feel and sound of water resistance.
• You have space for an 83-inch long machine.

Skip if

• You need a compact rower for small apartments.
• You require built-in heart-rate monitoring.
• You prefer a lightweight machine for easy moving.

Verdict: WaterRower Vintage Oak S4 BLE is a solid choice for rowers who value connected training and durable, USA-made construction. It fits users with adequate floor space who want a high-quality water resistance experience.

2 Best budget

WaterRower Solid Ash Wood Rower

Best for: Users seeking natural wood aesthetics and water resistance

Resistance Type

water

Intended Use

Home Use

Dimensions

83 × 22 × 21 inches

View on Amazon: WaterRower Solid Ash Wood Rower Affiliate link

This WaterRower uses water resistance to mimic open-water rowing. It is built from solid ash wood, offering a natural look and durable construction. The rail length is 83 inches, providing ample space for users of various heights. It folds upright for storage, measuring 82 by 22 by 20 inches when stored. This model suits those who want a low-impact, full-body workout that fits into home spaces without sacrificing stability.

Pros

• Solid ash wood construction for durability
• 83-inch rail length for tall users
• Water resistance mimics real rowing
• Folds upright for easy storage

Cons

• No monitor included in specifications
• Lacks Bluetooth connectivity data
• Manual resistance adjustment only

Good fit if

• You prefer the feel of water resistance over air or magnetic systems
• You want a rower that doubles as attractive furniture
• You need a sturdy machine for full-body cardio

Skip if

• You require a digital monitor with workout tracking
• You need Bluetooth connectivity for app integration
• You prefer a lighter machine for frequent moving

Verdict: WaterRower Solid Ash Wood Rower offers a premium, natural aesthetic with a long rail for comfort. It is ideal for users who value authentic water resistance and want a piece of equipment that enhances their home decor.

3 Best premium

WaterRower Club S4 Water Rower

Best for: Dedicated home gyms valuing craftsmanship

Resistance Type

water

Weight Capacity

103.5 lbs (with water)

Display Type

S4 BLE Monitor

Connectivity

BLE

Intended Use

Home Use

Dimensions

83 × 24 × 21 inches

View on Amazon: WaterRower Club S4 Water Rower Affiliate link

The WaterRower Club S4 is a handcrafted ash wood rower made in the USA. It uses a water-filled flywheel for smooth, self-regulating resistance. The included S4 BLE monitor tracks your workout data. At 83 inches long and 117 pounds, it is a substantial piece of equipment. It suits home users who want a durable, natural-rowing experience with reliable connectivity.

Pros

• Handcrafted solid ash wood construction
• Water resistance system for smooth motion
• S4 BLE monitor for data tracking
• Made in the USA

Cons

• Large footprint requires 83 inches of space
• Heavy at 117 pounds
• No remote control included

Good fit if

• You have dedicated floor space for an 83-inch machine
• You prefer natural water resistance over magnetic or air systems
• You want a rower built with sustainably sourced hardwoods

Skip if

• You need a compact rower for small apartments
• You want to store the machine in a closet
• You prefer digital connectivity beyond basic BLE

Verdict: WaterRower Club S4 Ash is a heavy, space-intensive rower for those who value handcrafted durability and natural water resistance over compact storage or smart app integration.

Specifications side by side

How to choose the right one

1. Check space requirements

   Measure your available floor area before buying. The WaterRower Vintage Oak S4 BLE measures 83 inches in length and 21 inches in width. You need enough clearance for the flywheel and handle movement. If your room is small, verify the dimensions carefully. Some models fold for vertical storage, but others remain long. Ensure you have space for safe operation. Check the width to ensure it fits through doorways and hallways. Proper spacing prevents accidents and allows for full strokes.

2. Compare water resistance

   All listed models use water resistance for a smooth, natural feel. The resistance level adjusts based on water volume, not a dial. You fill the tank to the marked line to set intensity. More water means more resistance during the pull. This type of resistance mimics rowing on a lake. It is self-regulating, meaning harder pulls create more drag. You do not need to adjust settings mid-workout. The sensation is consistent and quiet compared to magnetic or air systems. It provides a realistic rowing experience for home use.

3. Consider weight capacity

   Heavier machines offer greater stability during vigorous workouts. The WaterRower Club S4 weighs 117 pounds, making it very steady. The Vintage Oak S4 BLE weighs 108 pounds, also providing solid support. Heavier frames resist shifting when you pull hard. If you are a larger user or row intensely, choose a heavier unit. Lighter models may slide on smooth floors. Check the total weight to gauge build quality. A substantial weight ensures the rower stays in place. This durability supports long-term use and consistent performance.

4. Review monitor features

   The Vintage Oak S4 BLE includes the S4 monitor for connected training. This display tracks your workout metrics and syncs with apps. You can follow guided programs or view performance data. Other models may have simpler displays or none at all. Decide if you want digital feedback or a basic experience. The S4 monitor adds functionality for data-driven training. It enhances the workout by providing real-time insights. Check if the monitor is included or sold separately. Connected features can improve motivation and track progress over time.

5. Assess build materials

   Wood construction offers durability and aesthetic appeal. The Vintage Oak S4 BLE features a vintage oak finish. The Solid Ash Wood Rower offers a natural ash finish. These materials are sturdy and age well with proper care. Wood rowers are generally heavier and more stable. They also blend well into home decor. Consider the maintenance requirements of the wood finish. Regular oiling may be needed to preserve the look. Choose the wood type that matches your home style. The material affects both the look and the longevity of the unit.

Frequently asked questions